If you loved I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House, try The Blackcoat's Daughter
A bridge between a film you've already seen and one most people haven't. Here's what they share, and what the second one does that the first one doesn't.
You already loved

I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House
→
Try this next

The Blackcoat's Daughter
What they share
Both films are directed by Osgood Perkins, and they both carry the dread, slow burn mood tags, and they sit in Horror / Mystery territory. If that's the register that drew you to I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House, the second film will land in a comparable space — through a different lens.
dreadslow burn
What The Blackcoat's Daughter is
Upstate New York. Winter. Wind-chimes. Two Catholic schoolgirls remain behind during holiday break. One is plagued by nightmares, the other by a secret pilgrimage. Perkins delivers a glacial, gnomic riff on demonic possession.